Bedlam's 12th Night and What You Will at Central Square Theater
"The skilled quintet includes director Eric Tucker, Kelley Curran, Edmund Lewis, Susannah Millonzi, and Tom O’Keefe, all of whom play multiple roles. They bring Shakespeare’s play to life with a sheer joy in creation that proves infectious."
DeadDogPark at 59E59 Theaters
"Now is the time to see DEAD DOG PARK, ... the play's talented cast will keep you throughly captivated. They master the emotionally charged scenes that provide a rare, insider's view of the people affected by a high-profile, controversial event. The remarkable acting talents of this troupe bring the story to full life with fast-paced, perfectly timed dialogue."
"Dead Dog Park is proof that theater can be vocal, aware, present, raging and engaging ... Tom O’Keefe, in a humanizing performance, is the anti-hero Officer Rob McDonald ... In O’Keefe’s hands, Officer McDonald is an examination of the unsuccessful and undereducated social class. O’Keefe discovers something raw and fragile in Officer McDonald, a man who is, essentially, completely alone in the world."
Outside Mullingar at Pioneer Theatre Company
"Pioneer Theatre Company’s exceptional production of John Patrick Shanley’s Outside Mullingar featured superb performances by all four cast members. Max Robinson and Tom O’Keefe’s father-son relationship, full of nuance and depth, and the diffident chemistry between O’Keefe and Amy Bodnar was the best acting I saw on any Utah stage this year.
"The four actors — whether arguing or sharing stories — are so comfortable together that it's easy to accept that they've always known each other. As Anthony, Tom O'Keefe wears the uneasy air of someone who knows he doesn't fit in and wonders if he will ever find what he needs."
Twelfth Night or What You Will & What You Will or Twelfth Night
"O'Keefe was equally appealing and charming while tackling the jester Feste and the long-lost brother Sebastian (and Sebastian's sister and Cesario and more -- it's that kind of double bill). His singing and playing of tunes in Twelfth Night (he did the musical composition along with Ted Lewis) was very winning. And his Feste was a marvel. The Twelfth Night version of Feste was winningly sly and sexy, to the point where one wondered why Olivia didn't fall for him. The What You Will Feste was childlike without ever condescending. And his Sebastian was soulful, somehow letting you believe he fell immediately in love and would indeed get married at the drop of a hat. As with all the actors involved, I can't wait to see him again."
"Every so often, evidence arises that acting might just be the most satisfying profession on the planet.Take the company called Bedlam, which is putting on not one but two inspired productions of Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” in a small and airless room in the garment district that seats about 50, and making you feel like its members are the luckiest people alive."
Hamlet and Saint Joan (Theatre Bedlam)
"Mr. O’Keefe’s excellent Claudius, in 'Hamlet,' provides the most psychologically intricate interpretation."
"[R]ounded out by the first-rate chameleons Edmund Lewis and Tom O'Keefe."
"Tom O'Keefe… pull[s] fresh selves out of [his hat] like the colored scarves in a magic show."
"O'Keefe gives a poignant edge to Claudius."
"O’Keefe, who does a splendid job portraying the church hierarchy, everyone from Peter Cauchon and Archbishop Rheims to D’Estivet, also does an exquisite job as the high-minded Inquisitor, handling his long, difficult speeches with ease. Of all the performers, O’Keefe amazed us with the dexterity of his transitions from one character to another—turning on a dime."
— Robert Michael Oliver, Marlyand Theatre Guide